Mar 01, 2012 the second thrust of the prodrivers license argument money lies in the fact tougher immigration laws in general result in devastating economic losses. If you have a persons who is honorable and has come to this country to make a better life fro themself and their families and the opportunity to perform an honest job is vaiable to them, then that person should have every right to get a valid drivers license. Many of the terrorists involved in the world trade center attacks, for example, had valid drivers licenses sundeen. Constitution, which holds that states must provide equal protection. Demographics of immigrants in the united states illegally. The primary reason states there are of them, plus the district of columbia and puerto rico issue driver s licenses or driving permits to undocumented drivers is public safety, and to reduce the cost of insurance to all drivers. That makes it possible for an undocumented illegal immigrant to receive a drivers license under ab 60. List of top 10 illegal immigration pros and cons green. Sep 14, 2011 as new mexico debates the pros and cons of letting illegal immigrants obtain a driver s license, the states republican governor susana martinez confirmed, on wednesday, that her grandparents came. Currently, state licenses contain information such as gender, height, weight, age and a photo, and also indicate veteran status and whether the individual is an organ donor. The pros and cons of an ab 60 driver s license offer an advantage to public safety while placing the security of some individuals at risk because they may not hold a current visa. Sb 67 will clear up confusing georgia drivers license requirements.
The pros and cons of illegal immigration are variable based on each community. Unauthorized residents may acquire a legal document that some may interpret as proof that they are authorized residents when they are not. States and dc that allow drivers licenses for people in the country illegally. If illegal immigrants were not allowed to obtain driver s licenses, they will continue driving, and it will not result in their deportment. What are the pros and cons of new york states green light. However, california blocked off this access in 1991, by asking all driver license applicants to provide proof of citizenship. S yet in mexico, the biggest source of immigrants to the rustic, there is not any debate.
Will offering illegal immigrants drivers licenses make american roads safer. Some can take on more illegal immigrants without issue, while others struggle with those who are already present. And while immigrants and allies wait for congress to act, some local leaders are stepping up. Legislature oks drivers licenses for undocumented immigrants the approval on the final day of this years legislative session was a surprise. Yet, this is not lawful, and would thus be considered voter fraud. Here is a sample of comments from readers on our stories and commentary about drivers licenses for n.
That is the purpose of these key points to start the conversation. If illegal immigrants are allowed to obtain drivers licenses, they will continue driving, and it will not result in their deportment. Getting a drivers license is a key benefit, especially for young immigrants. Providing a legal drivers license to one who has broken federal law so one can drive legally is an oxymoron. This paper examines the pros and cons of laws to grant drivers licenses to all immigrants, regardless of. Immigrants cross our borders for countless reasons. Pro 1 sanctuary cities encourage better relationships between undocumented immigrants and law enforcement. Mar, 2019 when american citizens find out that there is free healthcare for illegal immigrants and that illegal immigrants can obtain a driver s license, the citizens of america start the debates. Therefore, illegal immigrants could easily register to vote. Essentially, nothing about the status or behavior of immigrants changes if they are allowed to get drivers licenses. More driver license on the road could help safe more people and less accident.
Drivers license for illegal immigrants 763 words bartleby. Many believe that, for the safety of both illegal immigrants and us citizens, that illegal immigrants should be offered drivers licenses. Should illegal aliens be allowed to obtain a drivers license. Bill would let undocumented immigrants get driver licenses. Immigrant drivers license restrictions demonstrably do not deter illegal immigration, but they do cost lives. Pros and cons of political asylum in the united states 16. Can you think of any additional pro or con arguments. Should illegal immigrants be able to obtain drivers licenses.
His biggest concern was that the drivers license could be used as identification for air travel, potentially causing problems. The federation for american immigration reform warned it would lead to more accidents caused by uninsured motorists, and many would be hitandrun. Some state laws and college systems also allow certain students to pay instate tuition, regardless of their immigration status. Sep 17, 20 ruben navarrette says its about time that california permits illegal immigrants to have driver s license. Real id will also help prevent identity theft, which has increased by nearly 800 percent over the past 6 years. The possibility of a drivers license does not inspire undocumented. If illegal immigrants were not allowed to obtain drivers licenses, they will continue driving, and it will not result in their deportment. Many believe that, for the safety of both illegal immigrants and us citizens, that illegal immigrants should be offered driver s licenses. This legislation is seen as a significant victory for. To protect the community, all countries should allow illegal immigrants to get driver license, so that all drivers are protected on the road.
The only thing necessary in registering to vote is a drivers license. All other things being equal, illegal immigrants should be allowed to obtain drivers licenses. Driving without car insurance in colorado could cost you big. It is really difficult to make a choice about this issue because the problem is really controversial. People passionately debate the pros and cons of immigration reform. Jan 17, 2018 here is a sample of comments from readers on our stories and commentary about driver s licenses for n.
Jun 27, 2019 in january of 2015, a new law went into effect in california allowing undocumented immigrants to obtain drivers licenses. Should illegal immigrants in nj be able to receive a drivers license. New york state lawmakers on monday passed a controversial bill granting drivers licenses to illegal immigrants and gov. List of top 10 illegal immigration pros and cons green garage. The social impact is particularly relevant on united states roads, where illegal immigrants are driving without driver s licenses and without the driving instruction required in obtaining a driver s license. Josh harkinson of mother jones says undocumented immigrant cooperation with police is statistically proven to make sanctuary cities safer. In 2014, during a wgbhboston globe debate with democratic gubernatorial nominee martha coakley. Thats why i decided to prepare for you an essay, where we are going to figure out some pros and cons of this problem. Read on to learn about some of the pros and cons of granting drivers licenses for illegal immigrants and whats going on in a few states around. Many people feel that by offering licenses to these people that it will make roads safer. Undocumented drivers would need to pass a written and driving test to obtain a license, ensuring all drivers are certified to drive.
Should states issue drivers licenses to immigrants in the. One big benefit of issuing drivers licenses to undocumented. As new mexico debates the pros and cons of letting illegal immigrants obtain a drivers license, the states republican governor susana martinez confirmed, on wednesday, that her grandparents came. In the state of california, obtaining a driver s license did not require proof of legal presence since the early 1990s. Two years later, california explicitly committed to require proof of license to state issued driver s licenses by passing senate bill 976. States need to create practical, workable solutions, and denying certain immigrants.
Having a drivers license is vital to daily life, especially when people drive on the road. Illegal immigrants can get a legal drivers license that is exactly the same as an american citizens drivers license. Pros and cons of political asylum in the us forumdaily. In the state of california, obtaining a drivers license did not require proof of legal presence since the early 1990s. In an increasingly securityconscious america, access to driver s licenses by people in the country illegally poses serious risks and undermines u. Jun 18, 2019 the pros are public safety and lower auto insurance rates for everyone. Dmv will issue driver s licenses to some illegal immigrants. Giving undocumented immigrants drivers licenses improves. The ongoing debate about whether all ageeligible immigrants who can pass state driving tests should be able to obtain drivers licenses has been a distraction from the real issues that states face in promoting public safety and protecting their communities. Personally, i would prefer that everyone who may need to drive a vehicle receive some official training and at minimum be able to pass a drivers license test. Immigrants who are here in new hampshire illegally cannot get a drivers license. Hourslong dmv wait as undocumented immigrants apply for. More revenue for the states in drivers license fees.
In january of 2015, a new law went into effect in california allowing undocumented immigrants to obtain drivers licenses. Drivers licenses help to regulate the behaviors of people who operate motor. Pros, cons of licenses for illegal immigrants debated. Driving takes skills such as good eyesight, concentration, safety skills, and judgement. What are the pros and cons of allowing illegal immigrants to obtain a. Illegal immigrants, drivers license crash into american consensus. Jul 04, 2017 examples of why immigrants should receive a driver s license are included by attorney cruz, who is among a power panel of other attorneys who discuss the pros and the cons this new bill would. Hourslong dmv wait as undocumented immigrants apply for ny drivers licenses by ida siegal and ap published december 16, 2019 updated. The social impact is particularly relevant on united states roads, where illegal immigrants are driving without drivers licenses and without the driving instruction required in obtaining a drivers license. Should illegal immigrants be allowed to get drivers licenses in new.
Should illegal immigrants be allowed to get driver license. The security argument is spurious, because illegal aliens often use aliases and phony documents, so the aliens identity and residence is not established as a result of. Murder rates in san francisco, one of the oldest sanctuary cities, were at their lowest in 2014 with 45 murders since the 1989 city of refuge. Bradenton thousands of undocumented immigrants drive florida roads every year. Lower car insurance rates with fewer uninsured and unlicensed motorists on the road. I am talking about the illegal immigrants, who want to drive a car. It is up to each individual state to determine if the state wants to require proof of citizenship. Most us states require driverlicense applicants to submit a valid social security number and proof they are in the country legally. Proponents of issuing driver s licenses to illegal aliens have argued that it would improve national security and road safety. Should illegal immigrants be able to obtain drivers licenses in the u.
Drivers licenses for illegal immigrants in the united. Currently, otherwiseeligible daca recipients can apply for a drivers license in every state except nebraska. Constitution, which holds that states must provide equal protection to all people who live in their jurisdictions not just citizens. Nothing pro, only a few will want licenses because they want to stay under the radar the quick and simple answer. Read on to learn about some of the pros and cons of granting drivers licenses for illegal immigrants and whats going on in a few states around the country. The pros people who favor granting drivers licenses to illegal immigrants often cite the 14 th amendment of the u. Examples of why immigrants should receive a drivers license are included by attorney cruz, who is among a power panel of other attorneys who. Many are driving around untrained and uninsured, and pose a hazard to everyone on the road. Granting drivers licenses to undocumented floridians allows them. What are the pros and cons of allowing illegal immigrants to. Since 2007, 10 states have passed laws loosening driverslicense restrictions for undocumented immigrants like cruz and the growing national movement now has its.
Granting drivers licenses to undocumented floridians allows. At first, american citizens cant understand why when we have huge deficits and americas own citizens struggling that free health care is legally provided to. Pros, cons of licenses for illegal immigrants debated news. Should states issue drivers licenses to immigrants in the united. Proponents approve of the legislation because it allows the children of immigrant families who are often americans an opportunity to participate in society equally. Currently, you are in violation while driving under a foreign license for more than a month because it is only valid for 30 days. Two years later, california explicitly committed to require proof of license to state issued drivers licenses by passing senate bill 976.
Should states issue drivers licenses to immigrants in the united states illegally. Illegal immigrants, driver s license crash into american consensus. Ruben navarrette says its about time that california permits illegal immigrants to have drivers license. A drivers license or stateissued id card also works as an identification card. Granting drivers licenses to undocumented floridians. The pros are public safety and lower auto insurance rates for everyone. The pros people who favor granting driver s licenses to illegal immigrants often cite the 14 th amendment of the u. Nj drivers licenses fasttracked for undocumented immigrants. Ny lawmakers approve drivers licenses for illegal immigrants. The comments were culled from our online story chat and facebook. Readers react to drivers licenses for undocumented immigrants.
Many are driving around untrained and uninsured, and pose a. What are the pros and cons of new york states green. Proponents of issuing drivers licenses to illegal aliens have argued that it would improve national security and road safety. Drivers licenses for undocumented immigrants stir debate.
There are many challenges to getting a drivers license, and teenagers are not as inclined to get a drivers license anymore because of inexperience with driving and more challenging driving. Without a meaningful dialogue, this issue will remain unresolved. States need to create practical, workable solutions, and denying certain immigrants licenses because of their immigration status is. Jun 12, 2010 so you could argue it is a good idea to grant driver s licenses to illegal immigrants because illegal immigrants will take driver s education classes, pass driving tests, buy insurance, register their cars and be better, safer drivers, leading to a better, safer america. Jul, 2017 i am talking about the illegal immigrants, who want to drive a car.
Should undocumented immigrants be issued drivers licenses. If you have a persons who is honorable and has come to this country to make a better life fro themself and their families and the opportunity to perform an honest job is vaiable to them, then that person should have every right to get a valid driver s license. The pros and cons of an ab 60 drivers license offer an advantage to public safety while placing the security of some individuals at risk because they may not hold a current visa. Should drivers licenses and other id cards be issued to unauthorized immigrants. Drivers licenses for illegal immigrants in the united states. Providing licenses for undocumented workers to access their work will alleviate these losses. Dmv will issue drivers licenses to some illegal immigrants.
Citizenship status on drivers license citizen voices. List of top 10 illegal immigration pros and cons jul 30, 2015 aug 3, 2015 by green garage in 2012, there were approximately 11 million unauthorized immigrants in the u. Andrew cuomo is expected to sign it democrats in the state senate. Should illegal immigrants be able to obtain drivers. Jun 16, 2004 bradenton thousands of undocumented immigrants drive florida roads every year. Dec 09, 2019 why nj driver s licenses for undocumented immigrants are suddenly on the fast track. Politadvice if you are in danger in your home country, or you feel a real fear of persecution in the future, then this is one of the reasons for seeking asylum from the government of the united states of america. Why nj drivers licenses for undocumented immigrants are suddenly on the fast track. What are the pros and cons of allowing illegal immigrants.
The security argument is spurious, because illegal aliens often use aliases and phony documents, so the aliens identity and residence is not established as a result of the drivers license process. The possibility of a drivers license does not inspire undocumented immigrants to risk their lives crossing oceans, rivers, mountains, or deserts. So you could argue it is a good idea to grant drivers licenses to illegal immigrants because illegal immigrants will take drivers education classes, pass driving tests, buy insurance, register their cars and be better, safer drivers, leading to a better, safer america. Drivers licenses for illegal immigrants in the us debatepedia. A secure form of identification will make it more difficult for terrorists and other criminals to board a plane or enter a federal facility. Sep, 20 drivers licenses for undocumented immigrants stir debate. Should illegal immigrants be able to obtain driver s licenses in the u. In january of 2015, a new law went into effect in california allowing undocumented immigrants to obtain driver s licenses.
248 1194 999 71 40 51 665 1233 763 9 456 1302 818 268 332 485 1263 159 657 786 55 654 7 318 1214 1246 254 4 560 602 127